DOCUMENT: CLS-REBUILD · CLASSIFICATION: PUBLIC METHODOLOGY: SYMMETRIC · STATUS: ACTIVE
Founder or thinker

Is a republic a government of laws and not of men?

John Adams Founder or thinker

Read this first Extrapolation from the historical record, not the words of the founder.
From the answer library, published September 30, 2026. Pre-generated; every quotation was checked by code.
The short answer

John Adams

Quotes verified 15/15Coverage: PARTIALWhole record

John Adams believed that a republic is ideally a government of laws and not of men, where all individuals are equally subject to the laws. However, he acknowledged that the term republic is often misused and can be applied to various forms of government, including those that may not adhere to this principle. The confidence in this position is moderate, as the record provides both definitions and acknowledges the potential for misuse of the term.

  • undated “They define a republic to be a government of laws, and not of men.”
  • undated “That, as a republic is the best of governments, so that particular arrangement of the powers of society, or, in other words, that form of government which is best contrived to secure an impartial and exact execution of the laws, is the best of republics.”
  • 1807-07-20 “The word is so loose and indefinite that successive predominant factions will put glosses and constructions upon it as different as light and darkness; and if ever there should be a civil war, which Heaven forbid, the conquering General in all his triumphs may establish a military despotism, and yet call it a constitutional republic, as Napoleon has already set him the example.” OCR text

Extrapolation: John Adams's views on republics suggest that while the ideal is a government of laws, the term can be applied to various forms of government, including those that may not adhere to this principle.

OCR: 1 cited passage(s) are machine-read (OCR) text of old printings; quotations reproduce the stored OCR text, misreadings included.

The full record: ledger, contrary evidence, reasoning, sources

OCR: 1 cited passage(s) are machine-read (OCR) text of old printings; quotations reproduce the stored OCR text, misreadings included.

1. WHAT HE SAID (the record)

Record ledger

  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that a republic is a government of laws and not of men. He argues that if this definition is just, then the British constitution is a republic, as it is bound by fixed laws with a voice for the people. (key quote above)
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that a republic is a government of laws and not of men. He argued that the very definition of a republic is 'an empire of laws, and not of men,' and that the best government is one that ensures an impartial and exact execution of the laws. (key quote above)
  • BELIEF (1776-03-19): John Adams believed that a republic is a government of laws and not of men. He argues that the true idea of a Republic is 'An Empire of Laws and not of Men' and that this is the basis for a good government. "the true Idea of a Republic, is 'An Empire of Laws and not of Men'"
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that a government should be of laws and not of men. This is shown by his statement that in the government of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the legislative, executive, and judicial power shall be placed in separate departments, to the end that it might be a government of laws, and not of men. "to the end that it might be a government of laws, and not of men."
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that a republic could be a government of laws and not of men, as long as it was constituted on principles that included a first magistrate with sufficient authority to mediate between the nobles and commons, and where the executive power was balanced by the commons' control over the purse and laws. This belief is grounded in his analysis of ancient commonwealths, which he argued subsisted for a long time on such laws and principles. "On such laws and principles many of those ancient commonwealths, which so long subsisted, were formerly constituted."
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that a republic is a government in which all men, rich and poor, magistrates and subjects, officers and people, masters and servants, the first citizen and the last, are equally subject to the laws. This belief is based on his argument that this definition appears to be the true and only true definition of a republic. "a republic to signify only a government, in which all men, rich and poor, magistrates and subjects, officers and people, masters and servants, the first citizen and the last, are equally subject to the laws."
  • BELIEF (1789-07-17): John Adams believed that a republic is a government whose sovereignty is vested in more than one person, and he argued that the legislative power determines the nature of the government. He defined a republic as a government where the legislative power is not vested in one person, distinguishing it from despotisms and monarchies.
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that in a republic, laws and order must be preserved through means such as public attention and emulation, or through force and a standing army. He argued that republics rely on such methods to maintain submission to the laws, implying that they are governed by laws rather than by men alone. "To such means as these, or to force and a standing army, recourse must be had for the guardianship of laws and the protection of the people."
  • BELIEF (1807-07-20): John Adams believed that the term 'republic' is loose and indefinite, and that it does not necessarily imply a government of laws and not of men. He argued that successive factions may interpret it differently, and even a military despotism could be called a constitutional republic. (key quote above)
  • BELIEF (1819-03-31): John Adams believed that a republic is a government in which the sovereignty resides in more than one man, and he discussed the definitions of republic and liberty, but he did not directly address whether a republic is a government of laws and not of men. "The strict definition of a republic is, that in which the sovereignty resides in more than one man."

What cuts against it

  • ACTION (undated): John Adams wrote that in the government of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the legislative, executive, and judicial power shall be placed in separate departments, to the end that it might be a government of laws, and not of men. This implies that he believed in the necessity of a government of laws, but does not directly address whether all republics are such. "to the end that it might be a government of laws, and not of men."
  • BELIEF (undated): John Adams believed that an empire of laws is a characteristic of a free republic only, and should never be applied to republics in general. He argued that not all republics are free, and only free republics can be considered governments of laws rather than men. "An empire of laws is a characteristic of a free republic only, and should never be applied to republics in general."

2. HOW IT APPLIES (reasoning; inference is marked)

1. John Adams defined a republic as a government of laws and not of men, emphasizing that laws should govern rather than individuals. (key quote above)

2. He argued that the best form of government is one that ensures an impartial and exact execution of the laws, which aligns with the principle of a government of laws. (key quote above)

3. He believed that in a republic, all individuals, regardless of status, should be equally subject to the laws. "a republic to signify only a government, in which all men, rich and poor, magistrates and subjects, officers and people, masters and servants, the first citizen and the last, are equally subject to the laws."

4. However, he also acknowledged that the term "republic" is loose and indefinite, and that it can be misused to describe forms of government that are not truly governed by laws. "The word is so loose and indefinite that successive predominant factions will put glosses and constructions upon it as different as light and darkness."

5. This implies that while the ideal republic is a government of laws, the term can be applied to various forms of government, including those that may not adhere to this principle. Inference.

3. HIS TAKE

Record coverage: PARTIAL

The record is silent on whether all republics are necessarily governed by laws and not by men, and whether the term "republic" is universally applied to such governments.

Extrapolation: John Adams believed that the ideal republic is a government of laws and not of men, where all individuals are equally subject to the laws. However, he also recognized that the term "republic" is often misused and can be applied to various forms of government, including those that may not adhere to this principle.

Competing readings: One reading is that a republic is defined by being a government of laws, as stated in several of his writings. Another reading is that the term "republic" is too loose and indefinite to be applied universally to all governments that are governed by laws. The record itself supports both readings.

Confidence: Moderate, as the record provides both definitions and acknowledges the potential for misuse of the term "republic."

Sources cited (click to read the passage)
  1. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 4 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 107. Document: NO. VII.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-4/0009.08
  2. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 4 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 195. Document: THOUGHTS ON GOVERNMENT.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-4/0021.01
  3. Letters of Delegates to Congress, vol. 3 (documents dated Jan 1776 to May 1776): 54 documents (Paul H. Smith et al. (eds.), Letters of Delegates to Congress, 1774-1789, 26 vols., Librar). Document: John Adams’ Thoughts on Government. Date: 1776-03-19 (approx.). Source type: modern scholarly transcription. Passage id: john-adams/letters-of-delegates-vol03/0019.00. Variants: john-adams/letters-of-delegates-vol03/0019.01, john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-4/0025.02
  4. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 4 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)). Document: [CHAPTER II.]: THE FRAME OF GOVERNMENT.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-4/0031.00
  5. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 5 (Defence of the Constitutions Vols. II and III) (Charles Francis Adams (editor)). Document: CHAPTER FIRST.: ITALIAN REPUBLICS OF THE MIDDLE AGE. / FLORENCE.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-5-defence-of-the-constitutions-vols-ii-and-iii/0002.77
  6. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 5 (Defence of the Constitutions Vols. II and III) (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 454. Document: CHAPTER NINTH.: PADUA.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-5-defence-of-the-constitutions-vols-ii-and-iii/0011.02
  7. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 6 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 429. Document: THREE LETTERS TO ROGER SHERMAN, ON THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES . Date: 1789-07-17. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-6/0041.01
  8. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 6 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 244. Document: III.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-6/0008.08
  9. OCR text
    Correspondence between John Adams and Mercy Warren (1807) (Massachusetts Historical Society Collections, 5th ser., vol. 4, 1878). Document: JOHN ADAMS TO MRS. MERCY WARREN.. Date: 1807-07-20. Source type: old edited collection (OCR text). Passage id: john-adams/adamswarrencorr/0003.18
  10. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 10 (Letters 1811-1825, Indexes) (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 378. Document: TO J. H. TIFFANY.. Date: 1819-03-31. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-10-letters-1811-1825-indexes/0148.00
  11. The Works of John Adams, 10 vols.: The Works of John Adams, vol. 4 (Charles Francis Adams (editor)), p. 371. Document: POLAND.. Date: undated. Source type: old edited collection. Passage id: john-adams/adams-the-works-of-vol-4/0065.13

Quote check: PASSED (15/15 quotations verified verbatim)

Read more prior questions or ask a question of your own. How answers are built, checked and reviewed: How It Works.