DOCUMENT: CLS-REBUILD · CLASSIFICATION: PUBLIC METHODOLOGY: SYMMETRIC · STATUS: ACTIVE
Inquiry · Primary sources only

Who Sits at the Seat

Thirty-two voices, each answering only from their own words.

32 voices sit at the Seat: 29 live and 3 coming. Each answers only from their own recorded words. Open a card for who the person was, what of their writing we hold, and where their record is thin.

How the roster was chosen

The Seat has two groups of voices. The Founders are Americans who took a direct part in independence, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights and the fight over ratification. The Thinkers are the European and classical writers whose books ran through the political writing of the founding era.

Supporters of the Constitution (the Federalists) and its opponents (the Anti-Federalists) are both seated. Patrick Henry led the fight against ratification in Virginia, and George Mason refused to sign the Constitution because it had no bill of rights. The founding was an argument, and an honest account of it hears both sides, so they sit alongside Madison, Hamilton and Jay. The roster also includes voices such as Abigail Adams and Benjamin Rush, whose letters and essays record the period's arguments from outside the highest offices.

The thinkers, and the limit of the evidence

The fifteen influences follow Donald Lutz, "The Relative Influence of European Writers on Late Eighteenth-Century American Political Thought," American Political Science Review 78 (1984). Lutz counted the citations in 916 American political publications from 1760 to 1805.

That is a measure of PERIOD influence: which writers were prominent in the era's political writing. It is not proof that any particular founder read any particular thinker. Where a founder quoted, owned or discussed a writer, that is documented influence, and it is a separate question.

The Bible was the most-cited source in Lutz's count. It is kept as a shared reference that every engine can draw on, not as a voice.

John Trenchard and Thomas Gordon wrote Cato's Letters together, and the 1724 printing does not mark which of them wrote which letter. They therefore sit as one joint voice ("Cato"), with separate entries for each man's own other writings. That is why fifteen influences fill seventeen places, and the roster counts thirty-two voices in all.

Only their own recorded words

Every answer is built only from that person's own recorded words. Editors' notes, biographers' narrative and letters written to them are kept apart and labelled as someone else's words. Translations name the translator. Reporters' notes, reconstructions, fiction and scanned (OCR) text are marked where they are cited. Where the record is silent, the answer says so.

Founders

15 voices · 14 live · 1 coming

Americans with a direct part in independence, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights and ratification, Federalists and Anti-Federalists alike.

  • James Madison

    1751-1836
    Live

    Virginia delegate, notetaker of the Federal Convention, co-author of The Federalist, fourth president.

    Why at the SeatHe kept the record of the Federal Convention and co-wrote The Federalist: the Constitution's design, from inside the room.

  • George Washington

    1732-1799
    Live

    Commander of the Continental Army, president of the Federal Convention, first president.

    Why at the SeatHe commanded the army, presided over the Convention and set the first precedents of the presidency.

  • John Adams

    1735-1826
    Live

    Massachusetts lawyer and diplomat, author of the Massachusetts Constitution, second president.

    Why at the SeatAuthor of Thoughts on Government and the Massachusetts Constitution, and the president who signed the Sedition Act.

  • Thomas Jefferson

    1743-1826
    Live

    Author of the Declaration of Independence and the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, third president.

    Why at the SeatHe drafted the Declaration, and his record on liberty and slavery has to be read whole.

  • Benjamin Franklin

    1706-1790
    Live

    Printer, scientist and diplomat; signer of the Declaration and delegate to the Federal Convention.

    Why at the SeatThe eldest founder at the Seat, a printer and diplomat whose record runs from paper money in the 1720s to abolition in 1789.

  • Alexander Hamilton

    1755-1804
    Live

    New York delegate, co-author of The Federalist, first secretary of the treasury.

    Why at the SeatAuthor of the 1790 plan for a national bank and the 1791 opinion defending it; co-author of The Federalist.

  • John Jay

    1745-1829
    Live

    New York lawyer and diplomat, co-author of The Federalist, first chief justice.

    Why at the SeatNegotiator of the 1794 treaty with Great Britain, co-author of The Federalist and first chief justice.

  • Thomas Paine

    1737-1809
    Live

    Pamphleteer of the Revolution: Common Sense, The American Crisis, Rights of Man, The Age of Reason.

    Why at the SeatThe pamphleteer whose Common Sense made the case against monarchy and hereditary rule in 1776.

  • George Mason

    1725-1792
    Live

    Author of the Virginia Declaration of Rights; refused to sign the Constitution for want of a bill of rights.

    Why at the SeatAn Anti-Federalist: he wrote Virginia's Declaration of Rights and refused to sign the Constitution without one.

  • Samuel Adams

    1722-1803
    Live

    Boston organizer of resistance to Parliament, Committee of Correspondence leader, signer, governor of Massachusetts.

    Why at the SeatThe Boston organizer of resistance: the colonial case against taxation without consent.

  • Patrick Henry

    1736-1799
    Live

    Orator of the Revolution and leading Anti-Federalist; led the fight against ratification in Virginia in 1788.

    Why at the SeatThe leading Anti-Federalist orator, who warned that the Constitution would consolidate power.

  • Gouverneur Morris

    1752-1816
    Coming

    Pennsylvania delegate who wrote the Constitution's final text and Preamble; minister to France; senator.

    Why at the SeatThe delegate who put the Constitution's final text, and its Preamble, into words.

  • James Wilson

    1742-1798
    Live

    Pennsylvania lawyer and Convention delegate, theorist of popular sovereignty, original Supreme Court justice.

    Why at the SeatThe Convention's leading theorist of popular sovereignty, and one of the first Supreme Court justices.

  • Benjamin Rush

    1746-1813
    Live

    Philadelphia physician and signer; wrote on education in a republic, abolition, penal reform and medicine.

    Why at the SeatA physician and signer who wrote on what a republic owes its citizens: schooling, reform and health.

  • Abigail Adams

    1744-1818
    Live

    Letter-writer and political partner of John Adams; asked that the new code of laws "remember the ladies" (1776).

    Why at the SeatHer letters are a running political record of the Revolution, and an early voice on the legal standing of women.

Thinkers who shaped them

17 voices · 15 live · 2 coming

The European and classical writers on the Lutz-based roster: prominent in the era's political writing, which is not the same as proof that a given founder read them.

  • Montesquieu

    1689-1755
    Live

    French jurist whose Spirit of the Laws (1748) gave the founders the separation of powers.

    Why at the SeatThe writer the founders turned to on separating legislative, executive and judicial power.

  • William Blackstone

    1723-1780
    Live

    Oxford professor whose Commentaries on the Laws of England (1765-69) taught the founders English law.

    Why at the SeatThe founders' textbook of English law: the rights of Englishmen and the liberty of the press.

  • John Locke

    1632-1704
    Live

    English philosopher of consent, natural rights and the right of revolution (Two Treatises, 1689).

    Why at the SeatThe philosopher of government by consent and of the right to replace a government.

  • David Hume

    1711-1776
    Live

    Scottish philosopher and historian; his essays on parties and on a large republic shaped Madison's thinking on faction.

    Why at the SeatThe Scottish philosopher whose essays on parties bear on the founders' fear of faction.

  • Plutarch

    c. 46-after 119 AD
    Live

    Greek biographer and moralist; his Lives were the founders' handbook of republican virtue and its enemies.

    Why at the SeatThe ancient biographer of statesmen: the founders' examples of virtue and ambition in public life.

  • Cicero

    106-43 BC
    Live

    Roman statesman and orator; his natural-law republicanism (On the Laws, On the Republic, On Duties) ran through the founders' education.

    Why at the SeatThe Roman statesman whose natural law and idea of a republic ran through the founders' schooling.

  • Sir Edward Coke

    1552-1634
    Coming

    Chief Justice and author of the Institutes; champion of Magna Carta and the common law against royal prerogative.

    Why at the SeatThe judge who made Magna Carta and the common law a check on the Crown.

  • Cesare Beccaria

    1738-1794
    Live

    Milanese reformer whose On Crimes and Punishments (1764) argued for proportionate punishment and against torture and the death penalty.

    Why at the SeatThe reformer behind proportionate punishment and the case against torture and execution.

  • Live

    German natural-law jurist (Of the Law of Nature and Nations, 1672), a standard text in colonial colleges.

    Why at the SeatA natural-law jurist read in colonial colleges: how the law of nature binds people and nations.

  • Hugo Grotius

    1583-1645
    Live

    Dutch jurist, founder of the modern law of nations (The Rights of War and Peace, 1625; Freedom of the Seas, 1609).

    Why at the SeatThe founder of the modern law of nations: natural law, just war and the freedom of the seas.

  • Algernon Sidney

    1623-1683
    Live

    English republican executed in 1683; his Discourses Concerning Government defended resistance to tyranny.

    Why at the SeatThe English republican who died for the right to resist a tyrant.

  • Thomas Hobbes

    1588-1679
    Live

    Author of Leviathan (1651): an absolute sovereign as the price of peace, the view the founders set themselves against.

    Why at the SeatThe counterpoint: the case for an absolute sovereign, which the founders set themselves against.

  • James Harrington

    1611-1677
    Live

    English republican whose Oceana (1656) tied political power to the balance of property.

    Why at the SeatThe republican who tied political power to the distribution of property.

  • Emer de Vattel

    1714-1767
    Live

    Swiss jurist whose Law of Nations (1758) the founders cited on treaties, neutrality and sovereignty.

    Why at the SeatThe jurist the founders cited on treaties, neutrality and the rights of sovereign nations.

  • John Trenchard and Thomas Gordon, authors of Cato's Letters (1720-23), among the most widely cited English writings on liberty in the colonies.

    Why at the SeatCato's Letters: the English essays on liberty and free speech that the colonists quoted.

  • John Trenchard

    1662-1723
    Coming

    Whig pamphleteer against standing armies (1697-98) and co-author of Cato's Letters.

    Why at the SeatThe Whig pamphleteer against standing armies in time of peace.

  • Thomas Gordon

    c. 1691-1750
    Live

    Scottish Whig writer, co-author of Cato's Letters, author of the Discourses on Tacitus and Sallust.

    Why at the SeatCato's co-author, answering from his own later writings on government and tyranny.

Ready to ask? Put a question to one voice, or convene several at once. How answers are built and checked: How It Works.